By Amanda L. Gordon
August 16, 2016
Gathered in one of East Hampton’s oldest timber-framed houses, Robert Caro’s dinner party companions sat around an elegantly set table, hoping to hear what the author, historian and two-time Pulitzer winner makes of the election. The answer took a while.
It was Saturday evening, and Donald Trump happened to be holding a campaign fundraiser at the home of New York Jets owner Woody Johnson less than two miles away. Certainly, Caro wanted to oblige the three dozen people who’d paid generously to sit with him as part of the East Hampton Library’s Authors Night, its biggest annual fundraiser, and one that he’s participated in for 12 years.
Yet when the first question came — “what would Johnson think…” — the author who’s working on his fifth and final volume about Lyndon B. Johnson wasn’t immediately willing to guess. “I don’t know,” he demurred.
Before he would eventually lay out parallels between LBJ’s rise and the current election — and speculate on what it means for the future for U.S. policy — Caro wanted to step back and discuss where Johnson came from.
“As long as we’re here in the Hamptons in the lap of luxury, I’m going to tell you about something that’s like the other end of the earth, which is the Texas Hill Country,” he told the table. That’s where LBJ grew up with “incredible poverty” and “incredible loneliness” in a town with a population of about 400.
Johnson City was a place where you could earn a dime if you could get a dozen eggs safely to the next town over, 22 miles away, traveling by horse. “The people who lived there called it an island city,” Caro said. “It was an island in the middle of nowhere.”
For much of three years in the early 1980s, Robert Caro and historian Ina Caro, his wife, lived on the edge of Hill Country so he could conduct his famously exhaustive research. (“Why can’t you write a biography of Napoleon?” Caro recalled Ina saying.)
Very few ever moved away, so Caro interviewed Johnson’s first girlfriend and the pharmacist’s son, who told him the future president couldn’t buy gumdrops after school like the other kids who did so on credit, because his father didn’t pay his bills.
“In a small town that makes you an object of contempt,” Caro told the dinner party, standing alongside his wife.
The meal started with fennel soup with lobster and moved on to a buffet of poached salmon and tenderloin. It was hosted by Alex Goren and Brooke Kroeger, whose own book “The Suffragents,” about men who helped win women the right to vote, is due next year.
The next morning, Caro recalled the evening from the room where he writes in East Hampton — a bare-bones shack 50 yards behind his house, furnished with a typewriter and a giant corkboard where he posts outlines and notes. The Caros chose the property off a bumpy road about 26 years ago “to be away from the social swirl of the Hamptons,” he said from the shack in a phone interview.
And finally, Caro discussed the 2016 race from the historical perspective his guests had craved the night before.
“People think everything is unprecedented in America, and in many ways Trump is unprecedented. But in other ways there are some real similarities” between this year’s election and the 1964 race between Johnson and Barry Goldwater.
Caro outlined three parallels.
The first is a worry about nuclear weapons. “Today we have that element with Trump, and we had the same element in 1964,” Caro said. “In 1964 Barry Goldwater actually advocated giving control of tactical nuclear weapons to battlefield commanders — something he later denied, but Johnson made a real issue of with the Daisy Girl ad, the most powerful political ad ever made.”
In the ad, a little blond girl pulls petals off a daisy as she counts. A mushroom cloud expands. Johnson’s voice comes on saying that’s what the campaign is about: war or peace, life or death.
Another parallel: “Today you have Trump with his rants, his racist, xenophobic superpatriotic rants, against people of different religions or faiths. And in that ’64 election, you had a candidate who had voted against the Civil Rights Act,” Goldwater, and another who had fought to pass it, Johnson.
The third parallel is the potential political fallout from the vote.
“I may be the only person who sees a ray of hope here, if Trump is destroyed by a large margin,” Caro said. Johnson beat Goldwater with more than 60 percent of the popular vote, a landslide that left Democrats in control of the House and Senate.
“They could get anything through,” Caro said. “What did Johnson do? In the first months of ’65, he passes the Voting Rights Act, Medicare, he passes one education bill after another. Johnson got a lot of his war on poverty through largely because the Republicans had such a terrible candidate. His escalation of the Vietnam War later overshadowed these programs.”
“I believe Hillary Clinton will have an agenda for social justice, and if she has huge majorities, we may see huge advances,” Caro said.
National History Day contestants, please read this before you contact me.
The Suffragents won the Gold Medal in US History in the 2018 Independent Publisher Book Awards and was a finalist for the 2018 Sally and Morris Lasky Prize, presented by the Center for Political History. See “Summer Camp Newsletters” and Facebook posts from book-related appearances. Reviews, notices, and articles about my books are under their titles here. My articles are here.
January 29: Exhibition Opening Remarks: “Women Get the Vote: A Historic Look at the Nineteenth Amendment,“New York Society Library. February 23: “Public Values in Conflict with Animal Agribusiness Practices,” UCLA Law School, Los Angeles. March 13:“ The Suffragents,” Scarsdale Woman’s Club, Scarsdale NY. March 24: League of Women Voters, Albany County at the Bethlehem (NY) Public Library. March 25: “Judges, Lawyers, and Women’s Suffrage: Recognizing the Men Who Stood with Women on the Front Lines,” Gender Fairness Committee of the Third Judicial District, CLE, NY State Courts at SUNY Albany Law School, Albany NY. May 15: “The Republican Suffragents,” National Women’s Republican Club, New York City. August 7: “From Emma Goldman to the Marketplace of Ideas: Marking the 100th Anniversary of Free Speech at the Supreme Court,.” AEJMC, Toronto.